0 items in Cart
SmallPie Logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Eats
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Bakeshop
  • Our Team
  • Find Us
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • About
  • Eats
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Bakeshop
  • Our Team
  • Find Us
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

SmallPie Online Ordering Menu

2504 E OKLAHOMA AVE
MILWAUKEE, WI 53207
(414) 763-7067
8:00 AM - 7:00 PM
99% of 581 customers recommended
Announcement
Savory and sweet pies as well as other delicious treats. All baked fresh daily with flavors updated on here throughout the day! We are open for pick-up, delivery, and patio dining. Thank you for the love and support through all this: MKE, WI, and visiting friends!
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

SAVORY & SWEET PIES / DESSERT!
Savory Hand Pie 
Our signature item! Buttery flaky crust, seasonal fillings.
$8.00+
Sweet Hand Pie 
$6.00
Cream Pie and Specialty Pie Slice  
$7.00+
Quiche 
$7.00
Pot Pie 
$10.00
Huge Brownies 
$6.00
Big Cookie 
$4.00
Loaf Bread 
$3.00
Bagels 
$3.00+
Pumpkin Cake Square w/Maple Frosting (V) 
$5.00
Granola Bag (1 LB) 
$12.00

SANDWICHES, SALADS, & OTHER GOOD STUFF!
Sunrise Melt 
Yuppie Hill scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese, spicy mayo, fresh chopped herbs, and toasted baguette
$8.50+
Gas Station Breakfast Sammy 
Hometown Sausage chicken sausage, melty cheddar cheese, apricot jam, toasty bun
$8.00+
Garden Hummus Sammy (V) 
house-made hummus, vegan mayo, english cucumber, pickled red onion, red bell pepper, greens, topped with olive oil and special seasoning
$8.50+
Cheese & Apple Melt 
cheddar, smoked gouda, apple slices, toasted baguette, fresh spinach, ranch dressing
$8.00+
Pesto Turkey Melt 
turkey, house walnut pesto, extra provolone, tomato, toasty baguette
$11.00+
Southern Ham Melt 
smoked ham, melted provolone + cheddar, toasted baguette, mayo, dill pickles, sliced tomato, fresh spinach
$12.00+
Turkey Pepper Melt 
smoked turkey, calabrian peppers, provolone + smoked gouda, toasted baguette, fresh spinach, spicy mayo
$11.00+
Mushroom Ranch Melt 
sliced River Valley Ranch mushrooms, smoked gouda + cheddar, tomato, fresh spinach, toasted baguette, ranch
$8.00+
Demi Baguette 
$2.00
Granola Yogurt  Parfait 
Honeypie’s honey-almond granola, greek yogurt, honey, fresh fruit
$8.00
Potato Chips 
from Great Lakes Potato Chip Company, Traverse City, Michigan.
$2.00
Salad (Large) 
Made fresh daily.
$6.00
Salad (Small) 
Made fresh daily.
$3.00
Spreads 
$1.00

SCRATCH ICE CREAM
Ice Cream 
made locally by Scratch Ice Cream, Wawatosa, WI
$3.50+
Ice Cream Float 
$7.00

BEVERAGES
Anodyne Pie Blend Coffee 
$2.25+
House-Made Cold Brew 
$3.00+
Pilcrow Nitro Sweet & Creamy 
$5.00+
Hot Chocolate 
$3.50+
Mocha 
$3.75+
Door County Cherry-Limeade 
$3.00+
Rishi Black Iced Tea 
$3.00+
Iced Sport Tea 
$3.00+
Rishi Hot Tea 
$2.75
Rishi Iced Masala Chai Latte 
$3.00+
Arnold Palmer 
$3.00+
Natalie's Natural Lemonade 
$3.00+
Orange Juice 
$3.00+
Sassy Cow Whole Milk 
$0.00+
Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1/2 lb 
$7.00
Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1 lb 
$14.00
Decaf Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1/2 lb 
$7.00
Decaf Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1 lb 
$14.00

BOTTLED BEVERAGES
Wisco Pop Soda 
$3.25
Sprecher Soda 
$3.25
Mexican Coke 
$2.50
Topo Chico Sparkling Mineral Water 
$2.25
OpenWater Bottled Water 
$2.25
Diet Coke 
$1.50

COCKTAILS
Bloody Mary 
house bloody mix & vodka with an olive, pickle, smoked gouda chunk, lemon, and lime
$8.00
Wisco Bloody 
house bloody & montucky cold snack tall boy
$10.00
Light & Stormy 
Twisted Path light rum, Wiscopop ginger soda, lime juice
$7.00
Cherry Lime Crush 
Twisted Path gin (or vodka or blanco tequila) and our house-made Door County cherry limeade!
$7.00
Classic Old Fashioned 
bourbon, house cherry-orange bitters mix. garnished with orange and premium cherries.
$7.00
Vodka Lemonade 
Natalie’s fresh lemonade and vodka
$7.00
Gin & Tonic 
$7.00
Cold Brew Booze A Latte 
daily-made fresh cold brew, Twisted Path Dark Rum, cinnamon, sweetened condensed milk, all shaken together by hand
$8.50
Hot Booze a Latte 
Pie Blend dark roast, Twisted Path dark rum, sweetened condensed milk, cinnamon
$8.50
Orange Dream 
Scratch Ice Cream vegan cherry ice cream, vodka, and Sprecher orange dream soda
$11.00
Pieloma 
blanco tequila, Wiscopop grapefruit soda, and fresh lime juice
$8.00
Single Pour 
$3.00+

WINE
UNDERWOOD PINOT GRIS 250ml 
$5.00
UNDERWOOD ROSE 250ml 
$5.00
UNDERWOOD PINOT NOIR 250ml 
$5.00
Piemosa 
Natalie’s fresh OJ, brut, and Door County cherry juice
$7.00

BEER
MKE Brewing Co. MVP Hazy IPA 16 oz 
$4.00
Lakefront IPA 12 oz 
$4.00
Lakefront Riverwest Stein 12 oz 
$4.00
Good City Pils 12 oz 
$4.00
Montucky Cold Snack 16 oz 
$4.00
PBR 16 oz 
$3.00
Loon Juice Honeycrisp Cider 12 oz 
$4.00

MERCH
METAL STRAW 
$2.00
T-Shirt 
$20.00

GIFT CERTIFICATES

The perfect gift for just about anyone:)
Smallpie Gift Certificate 
Available in $10, $25, $50, and $100 increments
$0.00+

SUNDAY HOT HAM & ROLLS PREORDER

PREORDER FOR THIS COMING SUNDAY 1/24 *ONLY THIS ITEM WILL BE FULFILLED ON SUNDAY* - fresh rolls from our amazing bakeshop | all-natural, antibiotic-free, and insanely delicious ham from Beeler’s Pure Pork | grain mustard
Sunday Hot Ham & Rolls Preorder 
PREORDER FOR THIS COMING SUNDAY 1/24 *ONLY THIS ITEM WILL BE FULFILLED ON SUNDAY* - fresh rolls from our amazing bakeshop | all-natural, antibiotic-free, and insanely delicious ham from Beeler’s Pure Pork | grain mustard
$15.00

TO-GO UTENSILS & NAPKINS
Napkins 
$0.00
Fork 
$0.00
Knife 
$0.00
Spoon 
$0.00
Your cart is empty.
Powered by Menufy © 2021
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.