Your cart is empty.
SmallPie Online Ordering Menu
98% of 421 customers recommended
Savory and sweet pies as well as other treats baked fresh and updated daily! We are open for pick-up, delivery, and patio dining. Our patio is open for dine-in! (No more than 6 people per group for the safety of other customers and staff.) Our new preferred ordering method is in-person via walk-up ordering. We gladly will take any online and phone orders as well. If ordering by phone, please understand we are very busy taking orders in-person and assembling your orders. If phone line is busy or receiving no answer, please be patient and call back otherwise consider online or in-person ordering. Thank you for the love and support through all this: MKE, WI, and visiting friends!
SAVORY & SWEET PIES / DESSERT!
Savory Hand Pie
Our signature item! Buttery, flaky crusts surrounding seasonal meat and veggie fillings.
SCRATCH ICE CREAM
house bloody mix & vodka with an olive, pickle, cheddar gruyere chunk, lemon, and lime
Cherry Lime Crush
Twisted Path gin (or vodka or blanco tequila) and our house-made Door County cherry limeade!
Classic Old Fashioned
bourbon, house cherry-orange bitters mix. garnished with orange and premium cherries