0 items in Cart
SmallPie Logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Eats
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Bakeshop
  • Our Team
  • Find Us
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • About
  • Eats
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Bakeshop
  • Our Team
  • Find Us
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

SmallPie Online Ordering Menu

2504 E OKLAHOMA AVE
MILWAUKEE, WI 53207
(414) 763-7067
8:00 AM - 7:00 PM
99% of 781 customers recommended
Announcement
We are a small, neighborhood counter-service cafe specializing in handmade savory and sweet pies and treats.

*OPEN FOR CURBSIDE PICK-UP, AT-THE-DOOR PICK-UP, AND PATIO DINING MON-SUN 8AM-7PM.*
Start your carryout order.
Check Availability

SAVORY & SWEET PIES / BAKERY!
Savory Hand Pie 
Our signature item! Buttery flaky crust, seasonal fillings.
$8.00+
Cream Pie and Specialty Pie Slice  
$7.50+
Fruit Pie Slice 
$7.50+
Sweet Hand Pie 
$7.50
Quiche 
$7.00
Huge Brownies 
$6.00
Big Cookie 
$4.00
Granola Bag (1/2 LB) 
$6.00
Granola Bag (1 LB) 
$12.00

SANDWICHES, SALADS, & OTHER GOOD STUFF!
Cheese & Apple Melt 
cheddar, smoked gouda, apple slices, toasted baguette, fresh spinach, ranch dressing
$8.00+
Gas Station Breakfast Sammy 
Hometown Sausage chicken sausage, melty cheddar cheese, apricot jam, toasty bun
$8.00+
Mushroom Ranch Melt 
sliced River Valley Ranch mushrooms, smoked gouda + cheddar, tomato, fresh spinach, toasted baguette, ranch
$8.00+
Southern Ham Melt 
smoked ham, melted provolone + cheddar, toasted baguette, mayo, dill pickles, sliced tomato, fresh spinach
$12.00+
Sunrise Melt 
Yuppie Hill scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese, spicy mayo, fresh chopped herbs, and toasted baguette
$8.50+
Turkey Pepper Melt 
smoked turkey, calabrian peppers, provolone + smoked gouda, toasted baguette, fresh spinach, spicy mayo
$11.00+
Ruby's Bagel 
$3.00+
Granola Yogurt  Parfait 
Honeypie’s honey-almond granola, greek yogurt, honey, fresh fruit
$8.00
Salad (Large) 
Made fresh daily.
$6.00
Salad (Small) 
Made fresh daily.
$4.00
Sugar Waffle 
$4.00+
Demi Baguette 
$2.00
Potato Chips 
from Great Lakes Potato Chip Company, Traverse City, Michigan.
$2.00

SCRATCH ICE CREAM
Ice Cream 
made locally by Scratch Ice Cream, Wauwatosa, WI
$3.50+
Ice Cream Float 
$7.00

BEVERAGES
Arnold Palmer 
$3.00+
Decaf Pie Blend Coffee Beans (1/2 lb) 
$7.00
Decaf Pie Blend Coffee Beans (1 lb) 
$14.00
Door County Cherry-Limeade 
$3.00+
House-Made Cold Brew 
$3.00+
Iced Sport Tea 
$3.00+
Natalie's Natural Lemonade 
$3.00+
Orange Juice 
$3.00+
Anodyne Pie Blend Coffee 
$2.25+
Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1/2 lb 
$7.00
Pie Blend Coffee Beans - 1 lb 
$14.00
Pilcrow Nitro Sweet & Creamy 
$6.00+
Rishi Hot Tea 
$2.75
Rishi Black Iced Tea 
$3.00+
Rishi Iced Masala Chai Latte 
$3.25+
Sassy Cow Whole Milk 
$0.00+

BOTTLED BEVERAGES
Boylan Brewing Co. Root Beer 
$3.25
Diet Coke 
$1.50
Mexican Coke 
$2.50
OpenWater Bottled Water 
$2.25
Wisco Pop Soda 
$3.25

BEER
Rhinelander Shorty (7 oz) 
$3.00

COCKTAILS
Bloody Mary & Chaser 
house bloody & Miller High Life pony chaser
$10.00
Classic Old Fashioned 
bourbon, house cherry-orange bitters mix
$8.00
Piemosa 
brut champagne, Natalie’s fresh OJ, Door County cherry juice
$7.00
Single Pour 
$5.00+

WINE
Underwood Wine (250 ml) 
$8.00

GIFT CERTIFICATES

The perfect gift for just about anyone :)
Smallpie Gift Certificate 
Available in $10, $25, $50, and $100 increments
$0.00+

MERCH
METAL STRAW 
$2.00
T-Shirt 
$20.00

TO-GO UTENSILS & NAPKINS
Napkins 
$0.00
Fork 
$0.00
Knife 
$0.00
Spoon 
$0.00
Your cart is empty.
Powered by Menufy © 2022
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.